Opinión sobre qué estatura consideramos media, alta o baja.

khaled taban escribió:

charco escribió:That study is of 1.583 people. I have post a lot of study with many more samples, if you all wanna trust that study okay.  And i am agree with spaniard, white young people of USA are taller than spaniards, but young people of the usa are shorter than spaniards

How ? 177 cm is average for young people from all ethincities not white people , when Spain has 176.6 cm as spaniard said , we are taller not these days but from 2000 !

Spaniard: "Young white people in USA are on average 178.4 cm. In Spain 176.6". I am not agree with the 176,6 i think is 177-178 on young people i am just agreed with the point of that white americans are taller

charco escribió:

khaled taban escribió:

charco escribió:That study is of 1.583 people. I have post a lot of study with many more samples, if you all wanna trust that study okay.  And i am agree with spaniard, white young people of USA are taller than spaniards, but young people of the usa are shorter than spaniards

How ? 177 cm is average for young people from all ethincities not white people , when Spain has 176.6 cm as spaniard said , we are taller not these days but from 2000 !

Spaniard: "Young white people in USA are on average 178.4 cm. In Spain 176.6"

Where did I say 178.4 cm , I said 177 cm , isn't 177 < 176.6 ? lol
It's a very small difference but at least we can't say Spaniards are taller than Americans.

Para la media de estatura en España u otros países hay otros hilos:
https://www.foroalturas.com/t3609-estatura-media-en-espana
https://www.foroalturas.com/t878-estatura-media-en-el-mundo

charco escribió:

khaled taban escribió:

charco escribió:That study is of 1.583 people. I have post a lot of study with many more samples, if you all wanna trust that study okay.  And i am agree with spaniard, white young people of USA are taller than spaniards, but young people of the usa are shorter than spaniards

How ? 177 cm is average for young people from all ethincities not white people , when Spain has 176.6 cm as spaniard said , we are taller not these days but from 2000 !

Spaniard: "Young white people in USA are on average 178.4 cm. In Spain 176.6". I am not agree with the 176,6 i think is 177-178 on young people i am just agreed with the point of that white americans are taller

i edit it

This is what spaniard posted some time ago
Estatura media en EEUU. Estudio del CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention)
https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_03/sr03_039.pdf

Estatura media hombres en general (todas las razas) : 175,6 cm
Estatura media hombres de 20 a 29 años (todas las razas) : 176,2

Estadounidenses blancos (20-39 años): 178,3
Estadounidenses negros (20-39 años): 177,2
Estadounidenses hispanos (20-39 años): 172,3

charco escribió:

charco escribió:

khaled taban escribió:

charco escribió:That study is of 1.583 people. I have post a lot of study with many more samples, if you all wanna trust that study okay.  And i am agree with spaniard, white young people of USA are taller than spaniards, but young people of the usa are shorter than spaniards

How ? 177 cm is average for young people from all ethincities not white people , when Spain has 176.6 cm as spaniard said , we are taller not these days but from 2000 !

Spaniard: "Young white people in USA are on average 178.4 cm. In Spain 176.6". I am not agree with the 176,6 i think is 177-178 on young people i am just agreed with the point of that white americans are taller

i edit it

Ningún estudio dice 178 como la media española. Hay varios que dicen 177 y 176.

Eso es algo que pienso yo sin mas

charco escribió:This is what spaniard posted some time ago
[size=31]Estatura media en EEUU. Estudio del CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention)[/size]
[size=31]https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_03/sr03_039.pdf[/size]

[size=31]Estatura media hombres en general (todas las razas) : [/size][size=31]175,6 cm[/size]
[size=31]Estatura media hombres de 20 a 29 años (todas las razas) : [/size][size=31]176,2[/size]

[size=31]Estadounidenses blancos (20-39 años): [/size][size=31]178,3[/size]
[size=31]Estadounidenses negros (20-39 años): [/size][size=31]177,2[/size]
[size=31]Estadounidenses hispanos (20-39 años): [/size][size=31]172,3[/size]

Me acuerdo de ese mensaje, sí.

Podemos concluir que a nivel general para gente joven la estatura es similar entre ambos países (En torno al 176-177)

Si nos vamos por gente "blanca", entonces nos superan por poco (178.3 frente a 176-177)

Spaniard escribió:

charco escribió:This is what spaniard posted some time ago
[size=31]Estatura media en EEUU. Estudio del CDC (Centers for Disease Control and Prevention)[/size]
[size=31]https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/data/series/sr_03/sr03_039.pdf[/size]

[size=31]Estatura media hombres en general (todas las razas) : [/size][size=31]175,6 cm[/size]
[size=31]Estatura media hombres de 20 a 29 años (todas las razas) : [/size][size=31]176,2[/size]

[size=31]Estadounidenses blancos (20-39 años): [/size][size=31]178,3[/size]
[size=31]Estadounidenses negros (20-39 años): [/size][size=31]177,2[/size]
[size=31]Estadounidenses hispanos (20-39 años): [/size][size=31]172,3[/size]

Me acuerdo de ese mensaje, sí.

Podemos concluir que a nivel general para gente joven la estatura es similar entre ambos países (En torno al 176-177)

Si nos vamos por gente "blanca", entonces nos superan por poco (178.3 frente a 176-177)

If Spain average is 178 cm as charco said , then they are taller than most European countries execpt the Scandinivian countries and Netherlands.

I think the average height of people born in 2000 is 177-178. But that is not my point is just an observation. My point is that young spaniards are taller than young americans

charco escribió:I think the average height of people born in 2000 is 177-178. But that is not my point is just an observation. My point is that young spaniards are taller than young americans

This isn't true , but you don't want to be convinced . What about the girls ? usually if males and females in a specific country are together talelr than another .
how tall are the average spaniard girl ? American girl is 164 cm and white is 165 cm

Why is not true? You are agree with the point that young spaniards are 176,6 but not with the point of young americans are 176,2? You just take the information you like? I think spaniards young girls are 164

charco escribió:Why is not true? You are agree with the point that young spaniards are 176,6 but not with the point of young americans are 176,2? You just take the information you like? I think spaniards young girls are 164

177 cm not 176.2 cm , here is the evidence :

Khaled es de Albacete y sabe cómo somos los jóvenes de España.

khaled taban escribió:

charco escribió:Why is not true? You are agree with the point that young spaniards are 176,6 but not with the point of young americans are 176,2? You just take the information you like? I think spaniards young girls are 164

177 cm not 176.2 cm , here is the evidence :

I post some evidences about the average height of young people is not 176,6.

invitado22 escribió:Khaled es de Albacete y sabe cómo somos los jóvenes de España.

I am Hispanic and proud . I get your point but it does seem the average is 189 cm ( based on your intelligance )because you said 182 cm is short , didn't you ?

khaled taban escribió:

invitado22 escribió:Khaled es de Albacete y sabe cómo somos los jóvenes de España.

I am Hispanic and proud . I get your point but it does seem the average is 189 cm ( based on your intelligance )because you said 182 cm is short , didn't you ?

He was jocking hahahahaha

khaled taban escribió:

invitado22 escribió:Khaled es de Albacete y sabe cómo somos los jóvenes de España.

I am Hispanic and proud . I get your point but it does seem the average is 189 cm ( based on your intelligance )because you said 182 cm is short , didn't you ?

Yes, Invitado is medium-low (medio-bajo).

Una mujer de dos metros me torrea; claramente soy bajo. La duda ofende.

Anyway, my point is not about the average height because there is a lot of contradictory information and it is difficult to find an answer. The thing is that you were saying from the beginning  that young americans where taller than spaniards without having data and without living in Spain. Maybe americans are taller or maybe they are not but is not so clear

AlturaMediocre escribió:Decir que las estadísticas te importan 0 no va a ayudar en nada a que tu opinión (@keisuke) sea más o menos valida.
Tu simplemente te basas en tu percepción, los demás en los números. Y creo que todos podemos estar de acuerdo en que la ciencia, bien aplicada, no miente. Porqué la percepción tuya es diferente de la mía, y de la de los demás foreros. Pero los números son universales e iguales para ambos

Para que la gente lo entienda:
To let people understand it:

Imaginad que en una fábrica tienen en plan fabricar vigas de 6 metros de largo, imaginad ahora que las fabrican y miden 5 metros de media... ¿Las damos por válidas sólo porque han salido así? ¿Decimos entonces que el pedido del cliente está mal?
Imagine a factory where they have a plan to manufacture 6 meters long beams, now imagine that they make them and the average length of those beams is 5 meters... ¿We should take them as valid, only because they were manufactured in that way? ¿We should say that the client request is wrong?

Pues eso es lo que pasa con la estatura, que la media sea X ó Y sólo significa el estado actual de la población, no significa que ese sea el ideal. El ideal sale de estadísticas, pero no de medir a mucha gente, sino de cómo percibe la gente la estatura.
That is what happens with heigth, an average of X or Y only mean that this is the current status of population, it doesn't mean that this is the ideal. The ideal comes prom statistics, but not from measuring a lot of people, it comes from how people perceive stature.

Si el ideal está entre 180 cm y 190 cm, y mi cuerpo está por debajo de ese margen... ¡Lo que está mal es mi cuerpo, no el ideal!
If the ideal is between 180 cm and 190 cm and my body is under that margin... ¡My body is wrong, not the ideal!

No hay más cera que la que arde.
Nothing comes out of the sack but what was in it.

PS: la media debería ser de las personas sanas, porque si incluyes a personas no sanas, así cualquiera va justificando luego lo del "no deberías preocuparte por tu estatura", mientras luego vas por la calle y ves que tu cuerpo es una basura.
PS: the average should be from healthy people, because if you include not healthy people, it is very easy to say "you must not being worried about your height", while you walk on the street and you see that your body is rubish.

De media las personas no tienen dos piernas ya que hay mas personas sin piernas que con tres piernas.

Guys , I would tell you that from now on I will no longer write on here It's because I am insecure and disapointed about my height , that routine has destroyed my daily life , It's the reason why I was here.
Thanks for all members , It was pleasure to know you all , I probably will come back someday.
Peace <3

khaled taban escribió:Guys , I would tell you that from now on I will no longer write on here It's because I am insecure and disapointed about my height , that routine has destroyed my daily life , It's the reason why I was here.
Thanks for all members , It was pleasure to know you all , I probably will come back someday.
Peace <3

Do not go away. You are one of the most sensible writers here

You are right on your comments.